Module 9 Reflective Log



Complete the reflective log assignment titled, "To Kill a Mockingbird" in the textbox at the top of p. 177. Be sure to follow the instructions provided in the textbox. 
Use this link to access the video:
Gregory Peck plays the defense attorney Atticus Finch in the film To Kill a Mockingbird. The story is about a young man accused of rape. In this clip, Atticus Finch is giving his summation to the jury. He must be careful not to alienate the members of the jury, whom he regards as potentially biased against the defendant. Atticus first argues that the prosecution has not proved that a crime was actually committed. He then claims that the accused, Tom Robinson, could not physically have done the things that the prosecution claims. Atticus, believing that he must do more than make claims and logical arguments establishing reasonable doubt, then addresses a key question. Why would the accuser have lied about being raped by the accused? Atticus says he has pity for the victim and then he argues that by accusing Tom Robinson, she was attempting to rid herself of her own guilt. The defense then attempts to challenge the prejudicial assumption: All Negros are to be distrusted. Watch scene 28, "The Broken Code" (time code 1:31:40 to 1:38:55). Listen carefully to the claims and arguments made by Atticus Finch. Transcribe them, use the techniques in Chapter 5 to analyze and map them, and, using what you learned in Chapters 7 and 8, evaluate them. Explain your analysis and your evaluation. Would you have made the summation differently? If so, how?

Module 9 – Discussion



Fallacies such as the slippery slope, playing with numbers, and the false dilemma are often used by advertisers to influence viewers' attitudes. Review advertisements on television, online, or in magazines and identify an instance of one of the fallacies discussed in the chapter. Post the fallacy, how it occurred, and in what context. Where possible, provide a reference so that others may view your source. When you have done this, review your classmates' posts. Reply to the post that you believe contains the most blatant fallacy.

Module 8 - Review




1.
Peggy often affirms the consequent when reasoning with declarative statements. Which of the following would she be most likely to say?
A) Eating vegetables is the same as taking vitamins. So taking vitamins is the same as eating vegetables.
B) If you eat vegetables, you will get strong. You are strong, so that means you ate vegetables.
C) Vitamins are to vegetables as studying is to passing an exam.
D) If you take vitamins instead of eating vegetables, you will never get enough nutrients.
Correct Answer(s):          B

2.
"All crossing guards wear yellow. Jason does not wear yellow. Jason is not a crossing guard." This is an example of
A) applying a reason.
B) applying a generalization.
C) applying a paradox.
D) applying an exception.
Correct Answer(s):          D

3.
Larry often uses vague subject pronouns such as "it." This leads to fallacies of
A) composition and division.
B) false reference.
C) false classification.
D) denying the antecedent.
Correct Answer(s):          B

 4.
"Marcia is Kelly's classmate. So, Kelly is Marcia's classmate." This is an example of a
A) transitivity relationship.
B) proximity relationship.
C) reflexivity relationship.
D) identity relationship.
Correct Answer(s):          C

5.
Emily is a strong critical thinker. When she hears the statement "Maggie is Susan's biological sister," she
A) calls in an expert to confirm the statement.
B) questions the term "sister."
C) does not take the statement at face value.
D) infers that they have the same mother.
Correct Answer(s):          D

6.
Affirming the antecedent is a type of
A) truthful fallacy.
B) inductive argument.
C) logical fallacy.
D) deductive argument.
Correct Answer(s):          D

7.
"Everyone who has worked in a restaurant has made tips. Martin has never made tips." Which of the sentences below would make this into an example of applying an exception?
A) This means Martin is a mediocre waiter.
B) This means Martin works in an office.
C) This means Martin has never worked in a restaurant.
D) This means Martin has made a salary.
Correct Answer(s):          C

8.
Olivia is teaching a course on critical thinking. What example would she give her class to describe applying a generalization?
A) Some students work hard. Mark is not one of these students.
B) All students are slackers. Mark is a student, so Mark is a slacker.
C) Students never study before the test. Mark does, so he is a student.
D) No students like to study. Mark likes to study, so Mark is a student.
Correct Answer(s):          B

9.
Terms like "brother" and "greater than" are examples of
A) marked terms.
B) transitive terms.
C) reflexive terms.
D) relational terms.
Correct Answer(s):          D

10.
"Criminals use the telephone. My mother uses the telephone. My mother is a criminal." Assuming the mother is not a criminal, this is an example of
A) true causality.
B) correct deduction.
C) marked terminology.
D) false classification.
Correct Answer(s):          D

11.
"If you run every day, you will lose weight." Which of the following statements should be added to this to make it an example of affirming the consequent?
A) You lost weight, so you must have run every day.
B) You should keep running to lose more weight.
C) Losing weight is the only benefit of running.
D) Joint pain can be a side effect of running.
Correct Answer(s):          A

12.
"If you fail the test, it's because you didn't study. You failed the test, so you must not have studied." This is an example of
A) cataloguing the differences
B) reflecting the outcome
C) affirming the consequent
D) declaring the claim
Correct Answer(s):          C
 
13.
Which of the following statements about facts and logic is true, according the text?
A) Facts and logic are two different things.
B) Logic and facts are the same thing.
C) Facts are more valid than logic.
D) Logic is more trustworthy than facts.
Correct Answer(s):          A

14.
Marcie is using the affirming the antecedent template. She must use which of the following grammatical structures when constructing her argument?
A) Neither A nor B
B) Both A and B
C) If A then B
D) Not A and not B
Correct Answer(s):          C

15.
A unless B is a logically equivalent grammatical structure to
A) A only if B.
B) not A unless B.
C) if A then B.
D) A or B.
Correct Answer(s):          D

 16.
"Kylie, age 8, loves the violin. Professional musicians play the violin." What phrase would we add to make this an example of false reference?
A) Therefore, Kylie wants to be a professional musician.
B) Therefore, Kylie is not learning the violin.
C) Therefore, Kylie plays in an orchestra.
D) Therefore, Kylie cannot read music.
Correct Answer(s):          A

17.
Alana often uses the deductive argument that relies on the grammatical power of "if A, then B" expressions. What deductive argument does she use?
A) Disjunctive syllogism
B) Affirming the antecedent
C) Grammatical equivalencies
D) Applying a generalization
Correct Answer(s):          B

18.
Whenever we have a _________ that asserts that a given characteristic applies to each of the members of a class of objects, we can logically assert that a given individual or subgroup of individuals that are members of that class has that characteristic.
A) statistic
B) generalization
C) inference
D) assumption
Correct Answer(s):          B

 19.
What is an inductive argument?
A) an argument that presents its conclusion as true given the truth of the premises
B) an argument that deconstructs its conclusion based on the falsehood of its premised
C) an argument that presents its conclusion as probabilistic given the truth of the premises
D) an argument that constructs itself naturally given the falsehood of its claims
Correct Answer(s):          C

20.
What is a reflexivity relationship?
A) If x has a reflexive relationship to y, then y has the same reflexive relationship to x.
B) If x has a reflexive relationship to y, then x also has the same reflexive relationship to z.
C) If x has a reflexive relationship to y, then y cannot have the same relationship to x.
D) If x has a reflexive relationship to y, then y must have a reflexive relationship to z.
Correct Answer(s):          A